Print this page Email this page Users Online: 1182 | Click here to view old website
Home About us Editorial Board Search Current Issue Archives Submit Article Author Instructions Contact Us Reader Login
Export selected to
Endnote
Reference Manager
Procite
Medlars Format
RefWorks Format
BibTex Format
  Access statistics : Table of Contents
   2001| September-December  | Volume 14 | Issue 3  
    Online since March 19, 2013

 
 
  Archives   Previous Issue   Next Issue   Most popular articles   Most cited articles
 
Hide all abstracts  Show selected abstracts  Export selected to
  Viewed PDF Cited
LEARNING/TEACHING
Attitudes of Physicians and Medical Students toward Nutrition's Place in Patient Care and Education at Ben-Gurion University
Iris Shai, Danit Shahar, Drora Fraser
September-December 2001, 14(3):405-415
Objectives: To describe attitudes of physicians and medical students at one medical school toward the role of dietetic treatment in patient care and toward adding nutritional education into the medical school curriculum. Study description: A cross sectional survey was conducted at Soroka University Medical Center and Ben-Gurion University's School of Medicine. The attitudes of 67 physicians and 62 medical students toward nutritional treatment were determined using an attitudes questionnaire. Results: Despite recommendations in medical treatment protocols to use dietary intervention as the primary treatment for several chronic diseases, physicians did not rate nutritional treatment as the most important treatment for these conditions. Students rated the im portance of nutritional treatment significantly higher for each of the medical conditions presented than did practicing physicians (p=0.001 ). A lm ost 50% of the physicians reported not using nutritional treatment due to lack of time and awareness of the available options. Physicians and students rated the im portance of nutrition education in the curriculum equally. Physicians who rated nutrition treatment as im portant also felt the need to add this subject to the medical education curriculum. Conclusion: Physicians and medical students agreed that dietary treatment and nutrition education are im portant. Our results suggest that there is good reason to introduce nutrition topics into medical school curricula. Improved nutritional knowledge in physicians would improve the teamwork capacity between physicians and dieticians in the realms of curative care and public health.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  483 77 -
CAREER ISSUES
The Relationship between Previous Tertiary Education and Course Performance in First Year Medical Students at Newcastle University, Australia
Lieve De Clercq, Sallie-Anne Pearson, Isobel E Rolfe
September-December 2001, 14(3):417-426
Aim: The purpose of this study was to identify the relationship between previous tertiary education back ground and the performance of first year medical students at Newcastle University, A ustralia. Specifically, we examined degree type ( i.e. arts, science, allied health, nursing or other professional back grounds ), level of degree completion ( fully or partially completed ), academic achievement ( grade point average ) and whether or not students had postgraduate qualifications. The relationship between age and gender was also examined. Method: A ll students admitted to the medical course from 1990 to 1998 with previous tertiary education experience who entered via the "standard'' entry pathway and sat the end of year examinations were eligible for the study (N=303 ). The outcome measures were the results of first assessment ("satisfactory'' versus "not satisfactory'' ) and final assessment of the first year ("satisfactory'' versus "not satisfactory'' ). L ogistic regression was used to examine the relationship between predictor variables and outcomes. Results: In relation to first assessment results, students with a nursing and arts back ground were significantly more likely to receive a "not satisfactory'' assessment ( RR=3.9, 95% CI: 1.6 - 7.7; RR=2.9, 95% CI: 1.2 - 6.8, respectively ), as were females ( RR=1.8, 95% CI: 1.1 - 3.5 ) and students with a grade point average of less than a distinction average ( RR=2.8, 95% CI: 1.6 - 5.2 ). A t final assessment, students with a nursing background and those with a less than distinction average were more lik ely to receive a "not satisfactory'' result ( RR=20.7, 95% CI: 3.5 - 123.9 and RR=4.0, 95% CI: 1.2 - 13.9, respectively ); consequently, they were required to repeat first year. Conclusion: Our research suggests that there are some medical student groups who encounter more academic difficulties than others in first year. Identifying these students can assist medical schools to focus academic support appropriately.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  479 75 -
ASSESSMENT/EVALUATION
Assessing Confidence and Competence of Senior Medical Students in an Obstetrics and Gynaecology Clerkship using an OSCE
Margaret A Elzubeir, Diaa E. E. Rizk
September-December 2001, 14(3):373-382
Context: A ssessment of clinical confidence and competence of senior medical students during an obstetrics and gynaecology clerk ship using an objective structured clinical examination ( OSCE ). Method: A questionnaire was distributed to senior medical students (n=47 ) to assess preand post-OSCE self-perceived con; dence and competence in five clinical sk ills: history tak ing, performing pelvic examination, interacting and communicating with patients, clinical reasoning and dealing with difficult patient situations. Pre- and post-performance con; dence levels were compared and correlated with OSCE scores. Results: The five clinical sk ills were significantly interrelated (p=0.001 ). There was no significant difference in OSCE performances between male (n=16 ) and female (n=31 ) students. Pre- and post-OSCE confidence in performing pelvic examination was significantly higher in female than male students (p=0.01 ). Post-OSCE confidence in clinical reasoning and dealing with difficult patient situations only were significantly increased in both groups (p=0.01 and p=0.02, respectively ). Pre- and post-performance confidence levels were not significantly correlated to OSCE scores. Conclusion: Of five clinical sk ills rated, self-confidence in clinical reasoning sk ills and dealing with challenging or complex patient problems only were significantly increased after an OSCE assessing competence. The content of some of our OSCE stations thus enhance confidence in these sk ills but psychometric and other characteristics of the OSCE such as duration and performance feedback mechanisms need further investigation.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  457 83 -
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE
Teaching Sociology within the Speech and Language Therapy Curriculum
S Earle
September-December 2001, 14(3):383-391
In the United Kingdom, the Royal College of Speech and L anguage Therapists suggests that sociology should be included within the speech and language therapy curriculum. However, in spite of this, sociology is seldom given priority. A lthough the role of sociology with the curricula of other professions has been discussed, the role of sociology within speech and language therapy has not. Given the contemporary climate of competence-based training, the position of subjects such as sociology is being compromised. This paper sets out three reasons in support of including sociology within speech and language therapy by drawing on the distinction between a "personal education'' and a "semantic conjunction'' model of the relationship between theory and professional practice. First, it is argued that sociology mak es a valid contribution to an holistic approach to care-which is rapidly becoming the cornerstone of speech and language therapy practice. Second, this paper suggests that the inherent reflexivity within the discipline provides health professionals with an invaluable tool with which to engage in reflexive practice. Finally, it is argued that given the global emphasis on evidence-based practice, the study of sociology and sociological research methods equips therapists to interpret and conduct empirical research. This paper concludes by arguing that sociology should be viewed as an essential component of the speech and language therapy curriculum.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  457 73 -
COMMUNITY-RELATED ISSUES/EDUCATION
Best Practices in Community-Oriented Health Professions Education: International Exemplars
Ronald W Richards
September-December 2001, 14(3):357-365
Introduction: During 1998 - 2000, an international team of five researchers described nine innovative health professions education programmes as selected by The Network : Community Partnerships for Health through Innovative Education, Service, and Research. Each researcher visited one or two schools. Criteria for selection of these nine schools included commitment to multidisciplinary and community-based education, longitudinal community placements, formal linkages with government entities and a structured approach to community participation. The purpose of these descriptions was to identify key issues in designing and im plementing community-based education. Methodology: Programmes in Chile, Cuba, Egypt, India, the Philippines, South A frica, Sudan, Sweden and the United States were visited. Before site visits were conducted, the researchers as a group agreed upon the elements to be described. Elements included overall institutional characteristics, curriculum, admissions practices, evaluation systems, research, service, community involvement, faculty development, postgraduate programmes and the school's relationship with government entities. Here I describe the common features of each of the nine programmes, their shared dilemmas and how each went about balancing the teaching of clinical competence and population perspectives. Lessons learned: Based upon an analysis of the cases, I present seven "lessons learned'' as well as a discussion of programme development, institutionaliz ation of reform and long-term im plications for health professions education. The seven lessons are:( 1 ) PBL and CBE are not seen as independent curricular reforms; ( 2 ) student activities are determined based upon sensitivity to locale; ( 3 ) health professionals need to work collaboratively; ( 4 ) there is a connection between personal health and population health issues;( 5 ) population health interventions and treatment strategies need to be appropriate to local conditions;( 6 ) graduates need to advocate for patients and the community in the public policy arena; and ( 7 ) organiz ational change tak es a long time. Conclusions: Despite their differences, all nine exemplars are engaged in processes of organiz ational change. Schools are becoming more community-oriented and socially accountable, and all of these programmes have accepted two fundamental tenets: "take public money, give to the public'' and "place matters''.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  428 84 -
LEARNING/TEACHING
Identifying Medical School Learning Needs: A Survey of Australian Interns
IE Rolfe, S Pearson, RW Sanson-Fisher, C Ringland
September-December 2001, 14(3):395-404
Objectives: To survey interns regarding their opinion of medical school learning needs for a range of core skills. Methods: A random sample of interns practising in New South Wales, Australia, who graduated from the state's three medical schools were surveyed two-thirds of the way through their first hospital year. They were asked whether there was a need for further medical school education for each of 226 core skills. Skills were grouped into five themes: management of clinical conditions; clinical investigations; clinical procedures; core practice; and professional development. Results: Frequency distributions weighted for age, gender and medical school background were calculated for each item. The 20 most frequently identified needs related to examinations of the eye and ear, nose and throat; managing uncooperative patients and difficult patient interactions; prescribing; writing not for resuscitation orders and death certificates. A lso included were procedural needs related to ear, nose and throat; plastering and wound management; and needs for more education in the management of clinical conditions related predominantly to "acute'' cases such as anaphylaxis and diabetic k etoacidosis. Conclusion: Interns were able to discriminate between their needs for different skills and identified many core sk ills for which they perceived there was a need for more medical school education. The implications for medical education are discussed.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  423 70 -
POSITION PAPER
Curriculum Change and Strategies, Past and Present: Why Is It Taking So Long?
JJ Guilbert
September-December 2001, 14(3):367-372
For the last 30 years or more the old war songs of medical education (community orientation, active learning, etc.) have been repeatedly ventilated in meeting after meeting, article after article. But of the present 1642 medical schools on the planet, only about 100 members of The Network and a few other have put these principles into practice, more or less. Obstacles and constraints are known. Is it the system, or the leadership, or the university culture, or the accreditation rules, or all of the above that are responsible for this lack of progress? Still, some overcame the obstacles, some removed the constraints. It would be useful to be better informed about HOW it was done. I suggest that Education for Health: Change in L earning & Practice ( EfH ) should present more articles explaining HOW successful schools managed to DO IT or WHY they were NOT able to DO IT.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  391 79 -
PRACTICAL ADVICE
Meeting the Challenge of a Changing Teaching Environment: Harmonize with the System or Transform the Teacher's Perspective
Richard G Tiberius
September-December 2001, 14(3):433-442
The beliefs that teachers hold about the appropriate roles and responsibilities of teachers shape the ways they teach and the ways they think about teaching. In this paper I describe four teaching roles based on a taxonomy that I've recently developed. Teachers who are guided primarily by the Content Expert Role view themselves as experts who serve as resources, lik e book s or pictures. Teachers who are guided primarily by the Performance Role view themselves as agents who mak e learning happen by transmitting information or shaping students. Teachers guided primarily by the Interactive Role view themselves as guides who facilitate learning by interacting with learners. A nd teachers guided primarily by the Relational Role view themselves as engaged in relationships with learners for the purpose of helping them. Using examples taken from the health sciences I explain how each of the four teaching roles might succeed or fail depending upon the position that it occupies within a teaching - learning system. When teaching is viewed as part of a system, not as something a teacher does to a learner, teachers are successful if their particular contribution to the system is essential to the learning system. I also describe the process whereby teachers expand their belief system to include more roles. Such changes in belief systems are major shifts that qualify as "perspective transformations''. Perspective transformations tak e place slowly and are typically attended by strong emotions. I end this paper with advice to teachers regarding ways they can harmoniz e with the educational system or face the challenge of perspective transformation.
[ABSTRACT]   Full text not available  [PDF]
  382 71 -
COMMENTARY
Sociology ( and All the Behavioral Sciences ) Have a Place in All the Health Professions: Commentary on "Teaching Sociology within the Speech and Language Therapy Curriculum''
Clint W Snyder
September-December 2001, 14(3):392-393
Full text not available  [PDF]
  270 91 -
BRIEF COMMUNICATION
Integrating Global Health and Medicine into the Medical Curriculum
J Urkin, M Alkan, Y Henkin, S Baram, R Deckelbaum, P Cooper, CZ Margolis
September-December 2001, 14(3):427-431
Full text not available  [PDF]
  267 62 -
MAKING A DIFFERENCE
An Interview of Ron Richards
Jane Westberg
September-December 2001, 14(3):443-448
Full text not available  [PDF]
  228 68 -
EDITORIAL
Reflections on Change: Educational and Institutional Implications of "Regression Toward the Mean''
Hilliard Jason
September-December 2001, 14(3):351-355
Full text not available  [PDF]
  228 62 -
BOOK REVIEW
Transforming Nursing Education Through Problem-Based Learning
Cheryl L Schriner
September-December 2001, 14(3):450-451
Full text not available  [PDF]
  212 77 -
Addressing the Needs of People: Best Practices in Community-Oriented Health Professions Education
Kate Cauley
September-December 2001, 14(3):449-450
Full text not available  [PDF]
  218 65 -
EDITORS NOTES
Editor's Notes
Hilliard Jason
September-December 2001, 14(3):347-349
Full text not available  [PDF]
  204 59 -
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
The search for HR continues: WHO's General Programme of Work 2002 - 2005 and the World Health Report 2001 on Mental Health
JJ Guilbert
September-December 2001, 14(3):452-453
Full text not available  [PDF]
  179 59 -
Feedback
Resources